Monday, January 10, 2011

Vegetables and Salts

Two additional reasons for adding salt to vegetables are to either mask the bad tastes some vegetables may have, or to be a preservative for vegetables that may be stored for an extended period (eg. pickling). We conducted controlled experiments by cooking green beans in salt solution and separately in plain water. These experiments led us to conclude that salt water preserves the color and texture, accentuates the flavor and cooks the vegetables faster.
The second experiment we conducted was to cook beans separately, for the same time in different pots, one with salt and another without. A member of our group was blindfolded and fed the two different samples and was able to identify, with ease, which was cooked with salt, and which was not. He claimed the flavor was a lot more intense in the one with salt. The group member did not look at the sample he was eating, and had no part to play in the cooking process. Moreover, the two were cooked for the same amount of time under the same heating conditions, making the test fair.
This image illustrates the difference in color of beans cooked with salt(left) and without salt(right).
In answer to the questions, we repeated the taste test with all three members of our group, and all guessed correctly. This indicates that it was unlikely to be a fluke. We used a random selection of beans from the same batch, which furthered the fairness of the test.
The length of cooking time would affect the test, as the beans cooked without salt would get soggy sooner. Therefore, if the salted beans were cooked a longer time, they might both be at the same level of sogginess, making it harder to identify them.
In experiments done with the lid on, we found that the lid causes the beans to turn a paler green, with a yellowish tint. This was an indication that the beans cooked faster when they were covered than they did uncovered. We assumed that the higher temperature caused by the increased pressure made the beans cook faster. 
Effects of cooking with/without a lid.
The effect of Baking Soda and Vinegar-
For our experiment, we added the same amount of salt to three different beakers, following which we added a small amount of vinegar to one and baking soda to the second. The third was used as a control. Beans were boiled in these three beakers and we found that the vinegar solution decolorized the beans extremely fast, leaving olive green colored beans. The baking powder solution made the beans a brighter green color. Thus cooking vegetables under acidic or alkaline conditions affects the end product. 
Effects of cooking in Acidic(left) or Alkaline(right) solutions.
The effect of Salt concentration-
We tested the boiling point of water at various concentrations of salt, by adding increments of 1.5g of salt to boiling water and measuring the temperature. A 0.5°C rise in temperature was observed for every 1.5g of NaCl that was added. Although this was only a small rise in the boiling point, it was a rise nonetheless. 
Effects of using different salts. L-R Sea Salt crystals, Morton Sea salt, No salt.



No comments:

Post a Comment